Green Heart of the Finger Lakes

The green heart of the Finger Lakes represents the beauty all around us. See more of these beautiful products>


Lauscha Glass Ornaments

made and imported from Lauscha, Germany


German Corner

The green heart of the Finger Lakes represents the beauty all around us. See more of these beautiful products.


Candies and Local Products

The Old Country Store carries a large Selection of domestic and imported candies.


Featured Products

Our Story

Jeff Wells spent over 30 years in Germany, where he met is wife and his two daughters were raised, but every summer he brought his family back to the finger lakes, and now the whole Wells family is back for good. In opening the Old Country Store, they are playing a leading role in revitalizing North Cohocton.

The Green Heart

The Green Heart of The Finger Lakes represents the beauty of our area. We have a variety of products featuring the green heart made by local artisans. Show your Finger Lakes pride!

Contact us!

German Corner

In our German Corner you will find a wide verity of European groceries, original Christmas Ornaments and Figurines from Lauscha Germany 

Candy Selection

Come and see our huge Bulk Candy selection, Candy Bars, Old Fashioned Candies that you haven’t seen in a long time, locally made Chocolate Barks and Brittle. All together we carry over 350 candy items. 

Local Products

We carry a wide verity of locally made Products like Naples Valley Honey, Wohlschlegel’s Maple Syrup, Arbor Hill Products, Nunda Mustard, New Hope Mills pancake mixes, Mountain Rise Granola, Nordic Farms Jams and Jellies, Java Gourmet Company and Seneca Salt Products and also locally made Cheeses.

Local Crafts

Our neighborhood is packed full of very talented Artists and Crafters. You will find very unique gift items from our local Potters, Wood Workers, Painters, Photographers and Crafters in our store. Most of our gift items are made within a 5 mile radius of the store. Can’t get anymore local than that.

Upcoming Movie Night: The Secret Life of Pets

SAT. April 1ST @6PM MOVIE THEATER NIGHT Indoor Screen on the Green: This months Movie Night will benefit the Naples Hospeace House Inc.  Ever jealous of the makeshift “Movie Theater” in Stars Hollow? Now we have our own! Join us for an indoor “Screen on the...
Read More